[IPAC-List] Call for new models for fire promotional exams

[Joel Wiesen]

The recent thread on Ricci prompts this email on an idea that has 
intrigued me for years.

We (and the fire service) might consider reconceptualizing fire 
promotional exams.  I see promise for improving 
productivity/effectiveness and reducing adverse impact.

Consider the job of Fire Lieutenant.  The current promotional exam 
process is designed to select people who can do the job of Lieutenant 
immediately on appointment.

Typically, the only entrance requirement for a promotional exam is 
several years experience in the next lower title (e.g., as a Firefighter 
for the job of Lieutenant).

To the extent that promotional exams test supervisory KSAPs, the current 
promotional exam system leaves firefighters largely or completely to 
their own devices to learn the job of Lieutenant.  (Yes, often there is 
a published reading list, however, the books do not address the 
complexities and range of application of strategy and tactics seen in 
firefighting, perhaps because real-world fire situations are so varied 
and complex.)

There might be alternative promotional exam systems that would have less 
adverse impact while maintaining or improving overall job performance of 
Lieutenants, especially new Lieutenants (say for the first 5 or 10 years 
on the job).  For example, the fire department might offer training 
classes for promotion to Lieutenant, designed so that successful 
completion of the classes could serve as an entrance requirement for the 
promotional exam.  It may well be that all students would master the 
material, as is typically seen in fire recruit training programs.  The 
promotional exam might then focus on past job performance (reliability, 
customer service, cautiousness, judgment, etc.)

Any thoughts?

Joel

P.S.  I suggest Fire Lieutenants might take 5-10 years to master 
strategy and tactics because there are so few fires in most 
municipalities (due to improvements in the building codes over past 
generations).  One Fire Chief told me he sends new Lieutenants to a 
nearby large city to get experience fighting fires, as there are so few 
fires in his community.



-- 
Joel P. Wiesen, Ph.D., Director
Applied Personnel Research
62 Candlewood Road
Scarsdale, NY 10583-6040
(617) 244-8859
http://appliedpersonnelresearch.com